
Srinagar, Nov 15: The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh has stayed proceedings before a trial court in a road accident case after a widow challenged the police decision to name her deceased husband as an accused, observing that criminal liability is personal and proceedings against a deceased person abate upon death.
Justice Shahzad Azeem, while hearing a petition filed by Arshida Bano under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, read with Article 227 of the Constitution, observed that naming a deceased person as an accused in a final police report creates an anomalous and incorrect public record.
The court passed the interim directions on November 4, noting that the legal heirs of a deceased person have a legitimate interest in seeking correction of such records, particularly when findings of negligence could have civil consequences.
The petitioner is the widow of Sheikh Muzaffar Ahmad, who died at SKIMS Soura on April 30, 2026, after sustaining injuries in a road accident on April 25 near Sheikhbagh Kangan on the National Highway.
Following the accident, FIR No. 35/2026 was registered at Police Station Kangan under Sections 106 and 281 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, and Section 122/177 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
After investigation, police filed a final report under Section 193 of the BNSS, naming the car driver as an accused and the deceased motorcyclist as accused No. 2 on grounds of alleged contributory negligence.
Challenging the investigation, the widow alleged procedural lapses, including failure to seize photographs and obtain CCTV footage, contradictions in the investigation and the shifting of her husband's body from SKIMS Soura to Sub-District Hospital (SDH) Kangan for postmortem examination.
She also questioned the decision to conduct the postmortem at SDH Kangan despite the availability of medical records at SKIMS Soura and the family's request for the examination to be conducted at the Srinagar hospital.
The petitioner sought disclosure of the circumstances surrounding the shifting of the body, production of case diaries, investigation records and witness statements, besides further investigation into the role of two women passengers who allegedly stopped the car while taking photographs.
She also sought seizure of their photography devices and stored data to preserve relevant evidence, along with an inquiry by senior police officers into the conduct of the investigating officer.
Taking note of the legal position, Justice Azeem observed that criminal liability is personal and cannot survive the death of an accused.
"While criminal liability is personal and abates on death, the judicial record remains," the court observed.
It further noted that proceedings against a deceased accused cannot continue, nor can charges be framed or a conviction or acquittal recorded against such a person.
Srinagar, Nov 15: The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh has stayed proceedings before a trial court in a road accident case after a widow challenged the police decision to name her deceased husband as an accused, observing that criminal liability is personal and proceedings against a deceased person abate upon death.
Justice Shahzad Azeem, while hearing a petition filed by Arshida Bano under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, read with Article 227 of the Constitution, observed that naming a deceased person as an accused in a final police report creates an anomalous and incorrect public record.
The court passed the interim directions on November 4, noting that the legal heirs of a deceased person have a legitimate interest in seeking correction of such records, particularly when findings of negligence could have civil consequences.
The petitioner is the widow of Sheikh Muzaffar Ahmad, who died at SKIMS Soura on April 30, 2026, after sustaining injuries in a road accident on April 25 near Sheikhbagh Kangan on the National Highway.
Following the accident, FIR No. 35/2026 was registered at Police Station Kangan under Sections 106 and 281 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, and Section 122/177 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
After investigation, police filed a final report under Section 193 of the BNSS, naming the car driver as an accused and the deceased motorcyclist as accused No. 2 on grounds of alleged contributory negligence.
Challenging the investigation, the widow alleged procedural lapses, including failure to seize photographs and obtain CCTV footage, contradictions in the investigation and the shifting of her husband's body from SKIMS Soura to Sub-District Hospital (SDH) Kangan for postmortem examination.
She also questioned the decision to conduct the postmortem at SDH Kangan despite the availability of medical records at SKIMS Soura and the family's request for the examination to be conducted at the Srinagar hospital.
The petitioner sought disclosure of the circumstances surrounding the shifting of the body, production of case diaries, investigation records and witness statements, besides further investigation into the role of two women passengers who allegedly stopped the car while taking photographs.
She also sought seizure of their photography devices and stored data to preserve relevant evidence, along with an inquiry by senior police officers into the conduct of the investigating officer.
Taking note of the legal position, Justice Azeem observed that criminal liability is personal and cannot survive the death of an accused.
"While criminal liability is personal and abates on death, the judicial record remains," the court observed.
It further noted that proceedings against a deceased accused cannot continue, nor can charges be framed or a conviction or acquittal recorded against such a person.
© Copyright 2023 brighterkashmir.com All Rights Reserved. Quantum Technologies