Education is too vital a sector to be left to chance, favouritism, or fraud. If we want to build a competent, ethical, and globally competitive generation, we must start by cleaning up our own house—and that begins with reforming the flawed promotion and recruitment policies in our education departments. Let the post of a teacher be one of pride, earned by merit, effort, and genuine qualification—not one that is purchased from the counter of a shady university or gifted through connections. Allowing incompetence into our classrooms not only deprives our children of essential knowledge but also hinders their potential for a successful future. Therefore, it is our responsibility to ensure that our education system is free from any form of nepotism or corruption and upholds the values of merit and integrity.
It is undeniable that education is the key to progress and prosperity in any society. At the forefront of this crucial process are teachers, whose impact extends far beyond the mere imparting of knowledge. They are the architects of future generations, moulding and shaping young minds to become productive and responsible members of society. The effectiveness of the education system hinges on the principles and values that govern it. Unfortunately, in recent years, there has been a growing concern about the flawed promotion and recruitment practices within many education departments. This issue has raised serious eyebrows as individuals with insufficient academic or professional qualifications have managed to climb the career ladder, often through the manipulation and fabrication of their credentials. This not only undermines the integrity of the education system but also deprives deserving and qualified educators of the opportunities they rightfully deserve. This is not only detrimental to the quality of education being provided but also undermines the principles of merit and fairness. Our education system must have a robust and transparent selection process to ensure that the best and most competent individuals are entrusted with the noble responsibility of shaping young minds. After all, our education system is only as strong as the people who run it, and it is imperative that we place the right people in the right positions for the betterment of our society and future generations.

The Reality

It is no longer a rare occurrence to come across Class IV employees, who were once recognised as mere peons or clerks, suddenly assuming the position of schoolteachers with a newly acquired degree from an unaccredited or questionable university. These degrees are often obtained through distance education programs that prioritise profit over academic rigour and quality education. Unfortunately, this trend is not limited to a few isolated cases but rather has become a widespread phenomenon in the public education sector. This troubling development can be attributed to the systemic flaws that allow individuals with purchased credentials to climb the ladder of promotion, based less on their competence and more on their ability to obtain these degrees. Of course, there is nothing wrong with the concept of upward mobility or providing opportunities for lower-level staff to improve their career prospects. It becomes a major issue when promotions are not based on merit, skills, or experience, but rather on the possession of a degree bought from a "degree shop." This is especially worrying in a sector as crucial as education, where the focus should be on qualified and competent individuals leading our future generation towards success.

Faults in the Promotion Mechanism

Several systemic loopholes are responsible for this unfortunate state of affairs.
Lack of departmental examinations: In the education system, promotions are often handed out without any departmental examination, leading to a lack of true evaluation and opportunity for growth. This issue is seen across the board, in both teachers and administrators, and can ultimately hinder the success of both students and faculty. Without regular departmental examinations, it becomes difficult to accurately gauge competency levels and identify areas for improvement. As a result, promotions can end up being based on seniority or personal connections rather than merit and qualifications. This not only leads to a stagnant and uninspired workforce, but it also deprives deserving individuals of rightful opportunities for advancement. The lack of departmental examinations in the education system is a disservice to everyone involved and can ultimately hurt the overall quality of education.
Lack of Verification of Academic Degrees: In many departments, degrees submitted for promotion purposes are not thoroughly verified for authenticity, accreditation, or relevance.
No Standardised Promotion Criteria: Promotions are often granted based on seniority or political patronage rather than performance assessments, training hours, or student feedback.
Politicisation of Education Jobs: Many teaching jobs and promotions are influenced by political connections rather than professional capability, undermining the sanctity of the education system.
Inadequate Training Requirements: Even when someone is promoted, there is little effort made to ensure they are adequately trained for the new role, especially in rural and remote areas.

Consequences on Education Quality

Unemployment: It is disheartening to see that the flawed promotions in our education system have led to qualified and highly educated individuals being left jobless, while those with less qualifications are given positions of authority. It is a sad reality that a clerk with a distance degree can be promoted, while a Ph.D. holder with years of hard work and dedication is forced to sit at home. The system that is meant to uplift and nurture the best and brightest minds is failing those who have put in the effort to excel and make a difference in their fields. It is time for a change, for the recognition and appreciation of true talent and merit, rather than promoting individuals based on arbitrary factors or nepotism. We must work towards creating a fair and just system where hard work and qualifications are valued and rewarded accordingly, providing opportunities for growth and success for all. Let us not only strive for personal success, but also advocate for a better future for the generations to come.
Devaluation of Teaching Standards: Teachers should ideally be trained in pedagogy, classroom management, subject expertise, and child psychology. Individuals entering the system through shortcuts often lack these essential competencies, leading to poor classroom delivery and disengaged students.
Moral and Ethical Implications: When undeserving candidates secure promotions and teaching roles, it demoralises genuinely qualified and hardworking educators. Over time, this fosters a culture of corruption and mediocrity rather than excellence.
Widening the Trust Deficit: Parents, students, and the community begin to lose faith in public education when they see that schools are being staffed by teachers who have neither the passion nor the preparation to teach effectively.
Stagnation of Innovation: Teachers who rise through unethical means are less likely to be motivated to improve their skills, experiment with new methods, or invest emotionally in students. As a result, the education system becomes stagnant.

The Injustices of the Present System

The current system exhibits a precarious inequality:
It disregards the fundamental tenet of meritocracy, which should serve as the basis for all government appointments.
It undermines the professional integrity of the teaching profession, reducing it to a secondary option rather than a preferred career.
It prolongs the cycle of socio-economic disparity, as children from disadvantaged backgrounds attending government schools suffer from inadequate teaching.
The Unfairness of the Current System: A Proposal for Rectification

Needed Reforms

To address the deeply ingrained issues present in the current system, a multi-faceted approach is required:

Implementation of Rigorous Degree Verification Procedures

A highly centralised and digitally-based platform should be instituted to verify all academic degrees submitted for promotions. To ensure the legitimacy of qualifications, the University Grants Commission (UGC) and the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) should maintain up-to-date records of recognised institutions. Degrees obtained from any institution that falls outside these parameters should be duly flagged and deemed inadmissible.

Adherence to Performance-Based Promotions

Like in other fields, promotions in education should be tied directly to measured teaching performance, attendance records, student outcomes, evaluations conducted by peers and parents, and continued professional development.

Mandated Teacher Training Programs

Individuals assuming teaching positions must undergo rigorous and mandatory training, either in-person or via online platforms. This training should cover topics such as curriculum design, pedagogy, and child development. A period of probation should ensue, consisting of continuous monitoring and evaluation.

Separation of Promotions from Seniority Status

While experience should certainly be held in high esteem, it must not serve as the sole determinant for promotions. A combination of professional experience, skill assessments, and relevant qualifications should be used as the basis for promotions. I believe that departmental examinations should be conducted for any promotions within the education system. These examinations would not only ensure that promotions are given based on merit but also create a fair playing field for all individuals. With standardised exams, the focus shifts from personal connections and biases to actual knowledge and understanding.

Proactive Measures Against Degree Mills

The government holds the responsibility of closing down unaccredited universities and institutes notorious for dispensing illegitimate degrees. Action must also be taken against individuals found guilty of submitting false certificates, including potential penalties and barring from any form of government employment.

Conclusion

Despite the increasing demand for qualified educators and the efforts made by various institutions to produce highly skilled graduates, the current promotion system in the teaching field often fails to recognise deserving candidates. While some individuals may have the privilege of being promoted from a lower position, such as Multi-Tasking Staff (MTS) to A teacher or lecturer, many qualified and ambitious individuals remain unemployed or underemployed. This is not because of their lack of qualifications or experience, but rather due to the unfair advantage given to those with connections or financial resources to "game the system." As a result, the education system loses out on potential educators who could have brought valuable contributions to the field. This unfortunate reality highlights the need for a more transparent and merit-based promotion system that not only benefits the individual employees but also creates a more diverse and dynamic teaching force for the betterment of education as a whole.

Email:------------------------ :essarbhat22@gmail.com